Back to insights
Insight | 7 November 2024

Optimising renewable energy integration - Asia Clean Energy Summit 2024 Keynote

Andrew Harpham, Director & Economist at Frontier Economics, spoke at Asia Clean Energy Summit 2024 on Optimising Renewable Energy Integration

Frontier Economics' Andrew Harpham speaks at Asia Clean Energy Summit 2024

Our team recently attended Asia Clean Energy Summit at Singapore International Energy Week, and our Director Andrew Harpham presented a keynote to discuss the challenges of integrating high levels of intermittent renewable generation into the electricity grid. Below, we provide a few of his slides and commentary from his keynote.

For more information, please contact us, or reach out to Andrew and our team.

Using Whole Electricity System Cost (WESC) for the economics of generation

Andrew began by discussing the very significant reductions in renewable generation costs over time, which have meant that renewables now have the lowest Levelised Cost of Electricity (LCOE) of any generation technology.

Slide: line chart of LCOE to 2050, with solar and wind lowest at under US$50/MWh, CCGT about $120 and OCGT over $200

However, the LCOE is an increasingly poor indicator of the economics of generation.

LCOE accounts for capital costs, operating costs, fuels costs (and carbon costs) of a technology.

A better guide to economic investment decisions is the Whole Electricity System Cost (WESC), which seeks to answer the question: what would be the impact of a given investment on overall system costs? WESC doesn’t just account for capital and operating costs of a given investment (which is what determines the LCOE) but also accounts for the extent to which a given investment leads to the avoidance of capital or operation costs for other generation, storage or network projects.

WESC accounts for impacts of each technology, including direct costs (as for LCOE), displaced investment, displaced generation, network impacts and balancing impacts.

Timing and response to price signals are crucial to renewable energy’s viability

When thinking about the WESC for renewable projects, it becomes clear that the timing of generation is crucial. In Australia’s electricity markets we are already seeing the market response for high levels of renewable investment: negative pricing during times of renewable generation is becoming increasingly common, with obvious impacts on the economics of renewable investment.

Slide: IEA chart of negative-price hours and renewable share, 2019–2023, in five regions; South Australia leads, passing 2,000 negative-price hours by 2023

Pricing signals shouldn’t be masked by changing market settings, but should be responded to

These pricing signals suggest that high levels of renewable investment can be better supported with options that manage renewable intermittency. These include load shifting and storage, but also dispatchable generation.

Slide: three options to integrate renewables: load shifting, storage (best when renewable output is high) and dispatchable generation (for renewable droughts)

Our energy42 modelling suggests that dispatchable generation will remain a crucial part of the generation mix, assisting to manage renewable droughts that load shifting and storage are not well equipped to manage.

Slide: modelled half-hourly generation in South Australia over a January 2040 week; batteries charge on midday solar and wind surpluses and discharge in the evening

Slide: modelled half-hourly generation in South Australia over a July 2040 week; with low renewable output, gas meets much of demand and prices spike

DOWNLOAD THE SLIDES

Related reading

All insights

What can we help you with?

Ask us

Get our latest insights

Sign up